top of page

A Local Family Business

Gardner Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency that specializes in auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance, and business insurance. As an independent agency, we’re able to help you, our clients, find the best possible insurance coverage for the lowest price possible.
Gardner Insurance was established in Madison, Indiana in 1979 by Bob Gardner (the “Smile-Maker”) and his wife Carolyn. Their daughter, Robin Goodknight, joined them in 1980 and still runs the agency today as the principal agent. Her son, Greg Goodknight, joined the Gardner team in 2013, representing the third generation in the family business.
As our clients, friends, and family know, Gardner Insurance takes pride in our business. We continue to retain our core values and principles as we move forward in the 21st Century of insurance. We have served the Madison community and surrounding areas since the inception of this agency, and we continue to pride ourselves on quality service, client loyalty, and helping make the best choices for you, our customers.

Types of Insurance We Offer

Get the right amount of coverage for your property!

Home Insurance Icon.png



Top insurance carriers and

speedy claim services!

Auto Insurance Icon.png

Let us help protect

your business

Business Insurance Icon.png

Protect your family's future

with a comprehensive

life insurance policy. 

Life Insurance Icon.png

Cover your assets as well as

your future earnings with an

Umbrella policy!

Umbrella Insurance Icon.png



bottom of page